Nicaea Library › Library

Plotinus: Complete Works, Vol. 4

The Enneads, in the order written: the One, Intellect and Soul. The Neoplatonism Augustine read before his conversion and the Greek Fathers corrected.

Edition: Project Gutenberg · www.gutenberg.org

Free to read, with no account needed. Public domain or openly licensed, with every source named.

From the opening: First Ennead, Book Two

Of Virtues.

I.--There is a difference between the virtues of the citizen, those of the man who essays to rise to contemplation, and who, on this account, is said to possess a contemplative mind; those of him who contemplates intelligence; and finally those of pure Intelligence, which is completely separated from the soul.

1. The civil virtues consist of moderation in passions, and in letting one's actions follow the rational laws of duty. The object of these virtues being to make us benevolent in our dealings with our fellow-human beings, they are called civil virtues because they mutually unite citizens. "Prudence refers to the rational part of our soul; courage, to that part of the soul subject to anger; temperance consists in the agreement and harmony of appetite and reason; finally justice, consists in the accomplishment, by all these faculties, of the function proper to each of them, either to command, or to obey."

2. The virtues of the man who tries to rise to contemplation consist in detaching oneself from things here below; that is why they are called "purifications." They command us to abstain from activities which innervate the organs, and which excite the affections that relate to the body. The object of these virtues is to raise the soul to genuine existence. While the civil virtues are the ornament of mortal life, and prepare the soul for the purificatory virtues, the latter direct the man whom they adorn to abstain from activities in which the body predominates. Thus, in the purificatory virtues, "prudence consists in not forming opinions in harmony with the body, but in acting by oneself, which is the work of pure thought. Temperance consists in not sharing the passions of the body; courage, in not fearing separation therefrom, as if death drove man into emptiness and annihilation; while justice exacts that reason and intelligence command and be obeyed." The civil virtues moderate the passions; their object is to teach us to live in conformity with the laws of human nature. The contemplative virtues obliterate the passions from the soul; their object is to assimilate man to the divinity.

There is a difference between purifying oneself, and being pure. Consequently the purificatory virtues may, like purification itself, be considered in two lights; they purify the soul, and they adorn the purified soul, because the object of purification is…

Keep reading in the library →

Contents (325 sections)

  1. Opening
  2. Title page
  3. Definitions of Happiness
  4. Whether Plants May Be Termed Happy
  5. Living Well Need Not Be Extended Even to All Animals
  6. Even They Who Define Happiness as Sensation Seek Higher Happiness
  7. Not Even Reason Is a Sufficient Explanation of Living Well
  8. Happiness Depends Exclusively on Interior Characteristics
  9. The Good Consists in Intelligence
  10. Happiness Must Be Something Human
  11. We Know We Have Reached Happiness When We No More Desire Anything
  12. Men Must Seek Their Happiness in That of Each of the Parts of Their Nature
  13. Necessary Things Are Those Whose Possession Is Unconscious
  14. Evils Which the Wise Man Can Support Without Disturbance of His Happiness
  15. No Misfortune Is Too Great to Be Conquered by Virtue
  16. Wisdom Is None the Less Happy for Being Unconscious of Itself
  17. Though Happiness Is Actualized Wisdom We Do Not Lose It When Unconscious. We Do Not Lose…
  18. Intelligence Is Not Dependent on Consciousness
  19. The Only Object of the Virtuous Will Is the Conversion of the Soul Towards Herself
  20. The Pleasures Claimed for the Virtuous Man Are of a Higher Kind
  21. In the Virtuous Man the Part That Suffers Is the Higher; Therefore He Really Does Not…
  22. Man Becomes Wise by Establishing a Spiritual Preponderance
  23. Two Wise Men Will Be Equally Happy, in Spite of Differences of Fortune
  24. The Wise Man Remains Unattached
  25. Third Ennead, Book Two
  26. Epicurus Taught Chance and the Gnostics an Evil Creator
  27. Particular and Universal Providence Assumed as Premises
  28. Providence Is Not Particular Because the World Had No Beginning
  29. How Intelligence Continues to Make the World Subsist
  30. The Sense-World Created Not by Reflection, but by Self-Necessity
  31. The World Should Not Be Blamed for Its Imperfections
  32. The World's Testimony to Its Creator
  33. Opposition Among Inanimate Beings
  34. Opposition Among Animals
  35. Opposition Among Humans
  36. Lack of Happiness Should Be Blamed on the Soul That Does Not Deserve It
  37. In Spite of Apparent Misfortune to the Good No Harm Can Happen to Them
  38. The Slavery of the Good and Victory of the Evil Seem to Accuse Providence
  39. Perfection Must Not Be Sought in Things Mingled with Matter
  40. Evil Is Only a Lower Form of Good
  41. It Is a Matter of Faith That Providence Embraces Everything Here Below, Even the…
  42. How Sense-Objects Are Not Evil
  43. The Good May Neglect Natural Laws Which Carry Rewards
  44. Death Is Better Than Disharmony with the Laws of the Universe
  45. Providence Should Not Be Extended to the Point of Suppressing Our Own Initiative
  46. Though Men Are Only Mediocre They Are Never Abandoned by Providence
  47. It Is Ridiculous to Complain of the Lower Nature of Animals
  48. If Unjust Acts Are Produced Astrologically Then Divine Reason Is to Blame
  49. Even Involuntariness Does Not Affect Spontaneity That Is Responsible
  50. Even the Shadows Are Necessary to the Perfection of a Picture
  51. It Is Reasonable for the Reason to Assign Souls to Different Ranks in the Universe
  52. Divine Justice Extends Also into Past and Future
  53. The Creator Is So Wise That All Complaints Amount to Grotesqueness
  54. Objection of Internecine War Among Animals and Men
  55. Responsibility Cannot Be Shifted from Reason Which Is Responsible
  56. Necessity of Internecine Warfare
  57. All These Changes of Fortune Affect Only the Outer Man in Any Case
  58. Does This Point of View Destroy Sin and Justice?
  59. This Problem Solved by Reason Being Derived from Intelligence
  60. The Unity of Reason Is Constituted by the Contraries It Contains
  61. The Whole Is Good Though Composed of Good and Evil Parts
  62. Founded on the Pun on Logos, as Character, Role and Reason, the Evils Are Shown to Play…
  63. Like Good and Bad Actors, Souls Are Punished and Rewarded by the Manager
  64. The Soul Must Fit Herself to Her Special Part in the Great Scheme
  65. Universal Reason Tries to Patch Up "Gags" by Undisciplined Actors
  66. This Illustration of Drama Allows Both Good and Evil to Be Ascribed to Reason
  67. Introduction to the Next Book
  68. Third Ennead, Book Three
  69. Souls Show Kinship to World-Soul by Fidelity to Their Own Nature
  70. Apparent Chance Really Is the Plan of a Divine General Providence
  71. We Cannot Question Our Order in the Hierarchy of Nature
  72. The Cause of Our Imperfections Is Distance from the Supreme
  73. Doubleness of Soul, Reasons and Providence
  74. Men's Better Nature Is Not Dominant Because of Their Sub-Conscious Nature
  75. Human Character May Be Result of Former Lives
  76. Causes of Deterioration
  77. This Providence Is the Normative, Curative, Sanative Element of Life
  78. The Plans of Providence Likened to the Foreknowledge of a Physician
  79. Prediction Does Not Work by Providence, but by Analogy
  80. Facts of Life Are Letters That Can Be Read
  81. Analogy Demanded by the Unity of God
  82. Evil Is Inseparable from the Good
  83. The Parable of the Vine and the Branches
  84. Fifth Ennead, Book Three
  85. Is Knowledge Dependent on the Compositeness of the Knower?
  86. A Simple Principle Can Have Self-Consciousness
  87. The Sense-Power of the Soul Deals Only with Exterior Things
  88. Functions of the Discursive Reason of the Soul
  89. Can Discursive Reason Turn upon Itself?
  90. The Highest Part of Discursive Reason Receives Impressions from Intelligence
  91. Why Discursive Reason Should Belong to the Soul Rather Than to Intelligence
  92. We Can Think in Conformity with Intelligence in Two Ways
  93. Man Is Self-Conscious by Becoming Intelligence
  94. Intelligence Is Not Divisible; and, in Its Existence, Is Identical with Thought
  95. Thought Is Identical with the Intelligible Which Is an Actualization
  96. Self-Consciousness More Perfect in Intelligence Than in the Soul
  97. The Soul Must Be Taught Self-Consciousness by Conversion
  98. Whatever Intelligence May Be Thought to Do, It Must Know Itself
  99. What Intelligence Looks Like in the Intelligible
  100. We Can Reach a Conception of Intelligence by Stripping the Soul of Every Faculty Except…
  101. Elevation of the Soul May Be Gradual, If Unable to Attain Immediate Elevation
  102. The Transcendent First Principle Has No Need of Seeing Itself
  103. The Contemplation of Intelligence Demands a Higher Transcending Unity
  104. How Intelligence Became Manifold
  105. The One Is the Principle of All Without Being Limited Thereby
  106. No Manifoldness of Any Kind Can Exist in the First
  107. Permanent Actualizations Are Hypostases
  108. The Supreme Is Absolutely Ineffable
  109. We Come Sufficiently Near to Him to Talk About Him
  110. Radiation of Multiple Unity
  111. The Supreme Produces Manifoldness Because of Its Categories
  112. The Good Must Be Superior to Intelligence and Life
  113. The Supreme as Superessential and Superexistent
  114. Ecstasy Is Intellectual Contact with Sudden Light
  115. Third Ennead, Book Five
  116. Love as God, Guardian and Passion
  117. Passional Love Is Twofold
  118. Love Is Recognition of Hidden Affinity
  119. Earthly Beauty Is an Image of Intelligible Beauty
  120. Beauty Is Immortal
  121. Passional Love May Be Elevating, Though Open to Misleading Temptations
  122. The Platonic Myth of Love
  123. Interpretation of the Platonic Myth
  124. Love, Like Higher Soul, or Light, Is Inseparable from Its Source
  125. Who Celestial Venus Is
  126. Love Possesses Divine Being
  127. Celestial Love Must Abide in the Intelligible with the Celestial Soul
  128. There Is a Lower Love, Corresponding to the World-Soul
  129. All Souls Have Their Love, Which Is Their Guardian
  130. The Higher Love Is Deity, the Lower Is a Guardian
  131. It Is an Error to Consider the Love as Identical with the World
  132. All Guardians Are Born of Need and Abundance
  133. Difference Between Deities and Guardians
  134. A Guardian Is the Vestige of a Soul Descended into the World
  135. Why All Guardians Are Not Loves
  136. Why the Guardians Are Not Free from Matter
  137. Soul Is a Mixture of Reason and Indetermination
  138. Guardians, as Well as Men, Are Urged by Divine Discontent
  139. Right Thoughts Possess Real Existence
  140. Jupiter, the Great Chief, or Third God, Is the Soul, or Venus
  141. Jupiter's Garden Is the Fruitful Reason That Begets Every Object
  142. The Object of Myths Is to Analyse; and to Distinguish
  143. Significance of the Platonic Myth of the Garden of Jupiter
  144. Significance of the Platonic Myth of the Birth of Love
  145. Love Is Both Material and a Guardian
  146. First Ennead, Book Eight
  147. Questions to Be Discussed
  148. A Definition of Evil by Contrast with the Good
  149. Nature of Divine Intelligence
  150. Nature of the Universal Soul
  151. Evil Exists as a Consequence of the Derivative Goods of the Third Rank
  152. Evil Possesses a Lower Form of Being
  153. Evil as Infinite and Formlessness in Itself
  154. The Primary Evil Is Evil in Itself
  155. Matter as the Secondary Evil
  156. The Soul Is Not Evil by Herself, but May Degenerate by Looking at Darkness
  157. Primary and Secondary Evil for the Soul
  158. Relation Between External and Internal Evil
  159. In What Sense Evils Are Universal and Unavoidable
  160. Evil Is Not Good's Qualitative, but Only Figurative Antagonist
  161. Good Implies Evil Because Matter Is Necessary to the World
  162. Existence of Evil Is Necessary as Last Material Degree of Being
  163. Matter Is Cause of Evil, Even If Corporeal
  164. Mastery of These Corporeal Dispositions Is Not Easy
  165. Definition of Primary and Secondary Evil
  166. How the Soul Comes to Know Vice
  167. How to See Matter: by Dialectic Abstraction
  168. Matter Is Both Without Qualities and Evil
  169. Matter as Deprivation Is Still Without Qualities
  170. Matter May Exist and Yet Be Evil
  171. The Soul Cannot Possess Evil Within Herself
  172. Relative Privation Is Impossible
  173. Evil as an Obstacle to the Soul
  174. Weakness of the Soul as an Explanation of Evil
  175. Weakness of the Soul Occurs Chiefly in Souls Fallen into Matter
  176. The Fall of the Soul as Descent into Matter
  177. No More Than the Existence of the Good Can That of Matter Be Denied
  178. Explanation of the Evil of the Soul
  179. Second Ennead, Book Three
  180. Of the Influence of the Stars
  181. Various Pretensions of Astrology
  182. Are Stars Inanimate?
  183. Are Stars Animated?
  184. Could "Cardinal Points" or "Declinations" Possess Any Influence?
  185. Absurdity of "Aspects," and "Houses."
  186. The Relations of Saturn and Mars Quite Illogical
  187. Fabulous Influences of the Moon
  188. Jupiter, Venus, and Mercury Also Considered Astrologically
  189. The Universe as a Single Harmony
  190. Absurdity of Various Astrological Theories
  191. The Stars Are Changing Signs Betraying the Universal Conspiracy of Purpose
  192. There Is a Natural Law Which Directs the Soul
  193. Wealth, Poverty, and Vices Are the Result of External Circumstances
  194. Significance of the Spindle of the Fates
  195. Which of Our Two Souls Is the Genuine Individuality?
  196. Numenian Doubleness, Mixture, and Divisible Soul
  197. Stars Announce Events Because of the Soul's Many Imperfections, and Accidents
  198. The Influences of the Stars Degenerate as They Reach Us
  199. Mingled Star Action Only Promotes or Retards Processes Already Natural
  200. Distinction Between What Is and What Is Not Produced by the Stars
  201. The Stars as the Followers of the Universal King
  202. Men as Souls of the Second Rank
  203. Any Occurrence May Be Due to Many Different Causes
  204. A Soul's Destiny Depends on the Condition of the Universe at Birth
  205. How Some Men May Master Their Fate: by Self-Victory
  206. Exact Psychology at the Root of Philosophy
  207. Is the Universal Soul Creative, but Not Preservative?
  208. Determinism Implies Degeneration of Races
  209. The Soul Does Not Cause Passions, Which Arise from the Seminal Reasons
  210. The Universe Is Harmony, in Spite of the Faults in the Details
  211. The Method of Creation
  212. Evils Are Necessary to the Perfection of the Universe
  213. Picture of the Structure of the Universe
  214. First Ennead, Book One
  215. Psychologic Distinctions in Soul
  216. The Soul as a Composite Aggregate
  217. The Soul Is Not Essence
  218. The Soul Uses the Body as Tool
  219. Separation of Soul from Body
  220. Primitive Relation Between Soul and Body
  221. Consequences of Mixture of Soul and Body
  222. Mixture of Soul and Body
  223. Aristotelian Hypothesis Considered
  224. The Living Organism
  225. Refutation of the (James-Lange) Theory of Emotions
  226. Not All Affections Common to Soul and Body
  227. Desire, Not Simultaneous with Appetite
  228. Soul and Body, by Uniting, Form an Individual Aggregate
  229. Sensation Implies Feeling Soul
  230. Soul-Light Forms Animal Nature
  231. Relation of Animal to Human Nature
  232. External and Internal Sensation
  233. Distinction in the Whole Organism
  234. Individual Relation with Cosmic Intellect
  235. Individual Relation with God and Cosmic Soul
  236. Soul Gives Life to Psychologic Elements
  237. Origin of Evils, Sins, and Errors
  238. Intellect DID Not Grasp the Object Itself
  239. True Conception Act of Intuition
  240. Modifications Derive from Foreign Sources
  241. Distinctions in "We" and the "Real Man."
  242. Real Man Differs from Body
  243. Function of the Common Part
  244. The Superior Principle Not Always Utilized
  245. The Animating Principle of Animals
  246. The Soul Both Impassible and Punishable
  247. Philosophic Separation Refers Not Only to Body, but to Passible Accretions
  248. How the Animal Nature Is Generated
  249. The Double Hercules Symbolizes the Soul
  250. Relation of the "We" and the "Soul."
  251. Intelligence Not Ours, but We
  252. First Ennead, Book Seven
  253. The Supreme Good as End of All Other Goods
  254. Participation in Good. Two Methods
  255. Permanence the Chief Note of Absolute Good
  256. All Things Depend on the Good by Unity, Essence, and Quality
  257. There Is No Unalloyed Evil for the Living Being
  258. By Virtue, Life Changes from an Evil to a Good
  259. Concordance of the Numbers of the 44 Paragraphs of Porphyry's Principles of the Theory of…
  260. First Ennead, Book Two
  261. First Ennead, Book Nine
  262. Of the Separation of the Soul and Body
  263. Second Ennead, Book Four
  264. Of the Conception of Matter (10)
  265. Third Ennead, Book Six
  266. Of the Incorporeal (3)
  267. Of the Impassibility of the Soul
  268. Of the Impassibility of Matter
  269. Of the Passibility of the Body (8-19)
  270. Third Ennead, Book Eight
  271. Fourth Ennead, Book Two
  272. Fourth Ennead, Book Three
  273. Union of the Soul and the Body
  274. Of the Descent of the Soul into the Body, and of the Spirit
  275. Fourth Ennead, Book Six
  276. Fifth Ennead, Book Two
  277. Of the Procession of Beings
  278. Of the Return of Beings to the First
  279. Fifth Ennead, Book Three
  280. Intelligence Knows Itself by a Conversion to Herself
  281. The Actualization of Intelligence Is Eternal and Indivisible
  282. Intelligence Is Manifold
  283. Sixth Ennead, Book Four
  284. Of the Incorporeal
  285. Relation Between the Incorporeal and the Corporeal
  286. The Incorporeal Has No Extension
  287. Relation of Individual Souls to the Universal Soul
  288. Sixth Ennead, Book Five
  289. The Incorporeal Being Is Entire in Everything
  290. Difference Between the Intelligible Being, and the Being of Sensation
  291. The Divinity Is Everywhere and Nowhere
  292. The Human Soul Is United to Universal Being by Its Nature
  293. Object of the Book
  294. Difference Between Sensation and Intelligence
  295. Of the Parts of the Soul
  296. Of the Difference of the Parts, and of the Faculties of the Soul
  297. On the Immateriality of the Soul
  298. Union of the Soul and the Body
  299. B. Notice of Ammonius by Hierocles
  300. I. Development in the Teachings of Plotinos
  301. II. Platonism: Significance, Progress and Results
  302. III. Plotinos's View of Matter
  303. IV. Plotinos's Creation of the Trinity
  304. Trinitarian Significance of Plotinos
  305. Non-Christian Origin of Paralellisms to Christianity
  306. Old Testament References
  307. New Testament References
  308. 1. Historical Relations Between Numenius and Plotinos
  309. 2. Numenius as Father of Neo-Platonism
  310. 3. Contrast Between Them
  311. 4. Direct Indebtedness of Plotinos to Numenius
  312. 5. Uncertain Indebtedness of Plotinos
  313. 7. Similarities Applied Differently
  314. 8. Philosophical Relations Between Numenius and Plotinos
  315. Importance in the Past
  316. Reliance on Punning
  317. Concordance to Plotinos
  318. Concordance to Plotinos (continued)
  319. Division, between universal soul and souls impossible, iv. 3.2 (27-390)
  320. Division, between universal soul and souls impossible, iv. 3.2 (27-390) (continued)
  321. Division, between universal soul and souls impossible, iv. 3.2 (27-390) (continued)
  322. Part in scheme, soul must fit itself to, iii, 2.17 (47-1071)
  323. Question, not to be asked by our order in nature, iii. 3.3 (48-1079)
  324. Question, not to be asked by our order in nature, iii. 3.3 (48-1079) (continued)
  325. Question, not to be asked by our order in nature, iii. 3.3 (48-1079) (continued)

How to cite it

Chicago
Plotinus. Plotinus: Complete Works, Vol. 4. Translated by Kenneth Sylvan Guthrie. Project Gutenberg, c. 253–270; translation 1918. https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/42933
MLA
Plotinus. Plotinus: Complete Works, Vol. 4. Translated by Kenneth Sylvan Guthrie, Project Gutenberg, c. 253–270; translation 1918. https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/42933
APA
Plotinus (c. 253–270; translation 1918). Plotinus: Complete Works, Vol. 4 (Kenneth Sylvan Guthrie, Trans.). Project Gutenberg. https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/42933

More from Philosophy